A Political Mystery: Amanda Cross’s The Puzzled Heart

It rained over the weekend.   It was a good time to read a stormy classic, but I chose not to roam the rainy heath with Thomasin Yeobright and the reddleman (The Return of the Native). Though usually fascinated by Heathcliff’s romps on the rainy moors and digging up of Catherine’s grave  (Wuthering Heights), I am less so when it actually rains here.  And Faulkner’s As I Lay Dying is too grotesque:   Cash Bundren, do not ride your mother Addie’s coffin in a flooded river!

No, the classics are too life-like.  And so I picked up a light mystery, Amanda Cross’s The Puzzled Heart.

Cross’s 14-book mystery series is set in academia.  Her amateur sleuth, Kate Fansler, is a brilliant English professor, and her assistant D.A. boyfriend, Reed, helps her with cases.  In later books, she and Reed are married, and he is a law professor.  The witty dialogue between Kate and Reed puts me in mind of the repartee between Harriet Vane and Peter Wimsey in Dorothy  Sayers’s books.

The Puzzled Heart, published in 1998, is surprisingly political. It is in part about the necessity for free speech at universities, and in part about the conflicts between the far right and the rest of us (liberals, moderates, etc).

At the beginning of the novel, Kate is deeply terrified and upset. Her husband Reed has been kidnapped by a far right-wing group, and they threaten to kill him if she tells the police. She is the real target:  the ransom is to be her recantation of her feminist beliefs in an article to be published in a right-wing publication.  Naturally, she will write the article–she will do anything–but she is terrified that they’ll kill him anyway.   She confides in her best friend Leslie.

This is not the first threat she’s had, but she never thought it would affect Reed.  Leslie wants to know, How many threats, and from whom?

“Several.  I didn’t pay that much attention.  Something called the League of Right-Wing Women wrote diatribes against everything I’ve worked for.  They seemed to be in favor of sexual harassment, battering women, date rape, and child abuse.  Perhaps that’s a bit strong.  But they certainly don’t believe any of these things happen on a large scale, and saying they do is all a plot to harry men.  Leslie, I just thought they were crackers.   In addition, I thought they were probably sending these warnings to many women.  I didn’t take it all that personally. The letter last night made it very personal.”

Carolyn G. Heilbrun, aka Amanda Cross

Kate hires another friend, Harriet, a private detective, to search for Reed. The investigation involves adopting a St. Bernard puppy, crashing a fraternity, dog-breeders, and a long look at the people in Kate’s life to identify any enemies.  She does not think she has any enemies.

Yes, the far right is involved, but it is also personal.  Who hates Kate?  Is it someone in the department?  Is it someone from her past?

Another stunning academic mystery!  Very fast-paced, very well-written.

Amanda Cross is the pseudonym of Carolyn G. Heilbrun (1926-2003) , the feminist critic best known for Writing a Woman’s Life and The Last Gift of Time: Life Beyond Sixty.  She was the first tenured woman in the English department at Columbia University, and a pioneering scholar of Virginia Woolf.   She wrote mysteries under a pseudonym to protect her academic career.

10 thoughts on “A Political Mystery: Amanda Cross’s The Puzzled Heart

  1. It must be thirty years or so since I read an Amanda Cross novel. I loved them set, as so many were, in an academic world I knew so well. At that time I’m sure there were only about half a dozen available in the UK at least. If there are fourteen then I have some catching up to do!


  2. I have enjoyed several of Cross’s books, but this one so much. The earlier books were more literary and the mystery usually involved some literary riddle or faction. In The Puzzled Heart the plotting and the activities of the right-wingers got far beyond probable. The puppy, however, was excellent.


    • It’s not her best, but the politics seemed surprisingly relevant, and I raced through it. Perhaps it seems more relevant now than when she wrote it!

      On Tue, Oct 10, 2017 at 6:29 AM, mirabile dictu wrote:



  3. I’ve never read an Amanda Cross — though I’ve read Heilburn and have two of her books :). Now I seriously want to — as if I don’t have enough to read and do :). It sounds good and help through a darker day.


    • They’re short, fast reads, well-written, and manage to be both an escape and an intelligent look sometimes at academic problems. (Joyce scholarship leads to murder in one of her books!) At first I thought the premise for The Puzzled Heart might seem dated, but no! It is all too pertinent to the times.

      On Tue, Oct 10, 2017 at 9:30 AM, mirabile dictu wrote:



  4. Oh, how I used to love reading these. I’ll have to go on a bookstore crawl and see if I can gather a few more to replace some copies-now-lost. Thanks for the reminder: so delightfully bookish, but also, as you’ve said, smart and topical!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s