Between the Lines: Reviews vs. Promos

vintage woman reading book stock-illustration-21375543-vintage-woman-reading-book-and-holding-cup-of-coffee

I hate to say this, I really do, but I have 10 review copies left over from last year.

How did I end up in this dysfunctional relationship?  With less space for reviews in newspapers and magazines, publishers want to give free books to bloggers, Amazon reviewers, Goodreads reviewers, etc.  In fact, it has reached the point where most Goodreads reviews seem to end with the sentence, “I am grateful to ____ for the opportunity to read an advance copy.”

Oh, dear.  We’ve all been there.  I’m not exactly grateful. In this relationship, guess who ends up doing the work?   But the problem here is my own.  Last year, only 6% of the books I read were review copies. So why did I request and/or accept so many books I never got to?  I seem to prefer to buy my books and read them at leisure.  And now I must send brief e-mails explaining these books left over from 2015 are not quite my kind of thing.

Do the publicists even notice?  Well, sometimes.

There is a shaky border between reviews and promotions these days.

Professional reviewers can be barracudas, but writers also complain that amateur reviewers trash their books with one-star reviews at Amazon before the publication date.  Well, I can’t address that problem.  The amateur reviews I read are usually kind.  Some of them are promotions rather than reviews–which is much better both for writers and publishers, I suppose.

I’m not against promotional writing.  It’s easy to spot, and you accept it for what it is.  Some promotional publications are very good.  We pick up BookPage free at the public library.  It features reviews, interviews, and columns.  Well, the reviews are not actually reviews:  they are what I call “prom-iews.”  In short, it is promotional writing.

But the trick?  BookPage picks good books.  The genres are clearly defined, so one knows it’s a debut novel aimed at millennials, a memoir, literary fiction, or history.  Never a negative word is written, but I often learn about a good book first at BookPage.  (N.B.  It’s where I read about MFK Fisher’s novel, The Theoretical Foot.)

The free biweekly newsletter Shelf Awareness also features  “prom-iews.”   I find it less interesting than BookPage (editors do matter).  But I do look at the book ads!

As for professional book review publications, we all know these.  The New York Times Book Review seemed like magic when I was growing up. On the internet we can also read The Washington Post, The Guardian, and many more.  Criticism is mixed into the long reviews, and, at least in the U.S.,  boundaries are set between reviewers and writers of books reviewed:  they are not supposed to know each other.  Of course, lines do get crossed.

And because the book publication editor assigns the reviews, there is none of this “gratitude” to the publisher.  Some serious reviewing is expected!

Anyway, I try to avoid review copies.  There are so many books I want to read…  I don’t need free copies of new books thrown into the mix.

6 thoughts on “Between the Lines: Reviews vs. Promos

  1. It’s so easy as a blogger to get sucked into the idea of lovely free books – but I’ve ended up lumbered with books I don’t actually want to read, so I’m being much stricter with myself and only asking for or accepting books I really do want to spend some time with. I thank the publishers who send me ones, yes, and they *are* the books I would choose to read anyway – so getting them as review copies is a bonus! 🙂


    • Yes, I got carried away, even though I know myself so well on this particular subject. Sometimes I get a great book I would otherwise not have read, like David Mitchell’s Slade House. (The bonus was my husband got to read it, too.) But mostly I read books by the dead!

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I’m trying to back away from review copies. I have two Netgalley books I got about three months ago still unread and a paperback review copy I received recently. I’ve turned down several others. I feel very relieved that that’s all I have at the moment.


  3. My problem is the opposite of yours! I would love to get free books to review!!! Being French and well in a rural area without a real library, almost no bookshops (or 30 kms away) and that do not sell books in English anyway, I am relying upon the resources of the house: no new book and often re-reads. How do I get free books to review, please? (said she, wailing).


    • Camille, anyone can sign up for Netgalley, a site where free digital copies are given to reviewers, bloggers, etc. Some books are free to everyone, most have to be requested. It takes a while to build a “rep” with the publisher, but you can really get some first-rate books there, especially after you’ve posted a few reviews. I have read some great ARCS from publishers but am now back to my reading of dead writers.:) I’m sure there are other sites like this.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s